Adam Back Critiques VC Nic Carter over Quantum Computing Fears

Blockstream CEO Adam Back has publicly criticized Nic Carter, a founding partner at Castle Island Ventures, for voicing concerns about the potential threats posed by quantum computing to Bitcoin. Back asserts that the Bitcoin community is already engaged in addressing these risks quietly, while Carter maintains that many developers are unaware of the serious quantum threats. The debate highlights differing perspectives within the Bitcoin community regarding quantum computing's impact on the cryptocurrency.

Key Takeaways

Adam Back rebukes Nic Carter for raising concerns about quantum risks to Bitcoin, calling it "uninformed noise."
Carter defends his views, claiming many within the Bitcoin community are in denial about quantum threats.
The discussion points to a divide among Bitcoin experts regarding the urgency and implications of quantum computing.
Some experts warn about looming threats in the next few years, while others believe such concerns may be exaggerated or premature.

Back's Critique of Quantum Concerns

Blockstream CEO Adam Back has taken a stand against Nic Carter, a founding partner of Castle Island Ventures, for what he considers unfounded worries regarding quantum computing's risks to Bitcoin. In a post on social media platform X, Back stated, “You make uninformed noise and try to move the market or something. You’re not helping,” just after Carter elaborated on Castle Island's investment in Project Eleven. This startup aims to safeguard Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies from quantum computing threats.

Back clarified that the Bitcoin community recognizes the importance of researching and developing defenses against potential quantum risks. However, he believes that this work is being undertaken quietly and without unnecessary alarm.

Carter's Response

In response, Carter argued that many Bitcoin developers are indeed in “total denial” about the threat posed by quantum computing. Although discussions about Castle Island Ventures’ investment resurfaced online recently, Carter had previously disclosed this investment in a Substack article on October 20. “I disclosed this in the first sentence of my main article on quantum. Can’t get more transparent than that,” he pointed out.

Carter's Quantum Awakening

Carter shared that his investment in Project Eleven was influenced by the startup's CEO, Alex Pruden, whom he claims “quantum pilled” him. He expressed growing concern regarding the impact of quantum threats on blockchains, stating, “I put capital behind my convictions, always have.” In anticipation of criticism, he insisted on being transparent about his financial involvement in the project.

He outlined several reasons why quantum computing could be a danger to Bitcoin, including:

Governments preparing for a post-quantum scenario.
The notion that Bitcoin serves as an "open bug bounty" for quantum supremacy.
The increasing investments in quantum technology firms.

Warnings from the Bitcoin Community

Carter is not alone in raising alarms about quantum computing's potential dangers. Charles Edwards, founder of Capriole Investments, warned in a recent post that Bitcoin could genuinely be at risk within two to nine years unless the network transitions to quantum-resistant cryptography.

Diverging Opinions

Despite these warnings, others remain skeptical. Entrepreneur Kevin O’Leary noted that utilizing quantum computing to undermine Bitcoin's security wouldn't be its most efficient application, suggesting that the technology would be far better employed in areas such as AI-driven medical innovations.

Adam Back, while acknowledging the importance of being "quantum ready," believes that the technology is still in its infancy and will not pose a serious threat for decades to come. He referred to current quantum developments as "ridiculously early," highlighting ongoing challenges in research and development.

Related: Anxiety around quantum risks is impacting Bitcoin's price, say executives
Magazine: Big questions: Would Bitcoin survive a 10-year power outage?
Quantum Computing
Sources: Pledditor

Sources: Nic Carter