JPMorgan's Alleged Short Position on Strategy (MSTR): A Potential 50% Price Increase Could Lead to Major Issues

Strategy, the largest public Bitcoin holder previously known as MicroStrategy, is caught in controversy over allegations that JPMorgan holds a short position on its stock amid falling Bitcoin prices. The bank's recent warnings about potential exclusion from equity indices, such as the MSCI USA Index, intensify concerns over Strategy's future.

Key Takeaways

JPMorgan may hold a significant short position on Strategy's stock (MSTR).
The stock has dropped 69% from its peak, and Bitcoin is facing a bear market.
JPMorgan warns of possible exclusion from major indices like MSCI due to heavy Bitcoin holdings.
Speculation suggests massive outflows could result from any MSCI decision.
Analysts indicate a potential short squeeze could occur if MSTR rebounds by 40% to 50%.

Strategy

Allegations Against JPMorgan and Strategy's Market Position

Strategy, formerly MicroStrategy and now the largest public holder of Bitcoin (BTC), is embroiled in controversy as rumors emerge that JPMorgan, one of the world's leading banks, is allegedly shorting its stock (MSTR). This comes as Bitcoin struggles in the market, with the asset experiencing a notable downturn.

With Bitcoin prices showing signs of a potential bear market, MSTR has seen a decline of 69% from its all-time high of $543 per share last year. Current Bitcoin trading is around $86,000, and the entire cryptocurrency market has lost approximately $1 trillion in market capitalization within the past month.

Risks of MSCI Exclusion for Strategy

The situation escalated recently when JPMorgan issued a warning about the potential removal of Strategy from prominent equity indices like the MSCI USA Index. Analysts at JPMorgan noted that the challenges facing Strategy are not solely due to the current drop in cryptocurrency values, which have seen Bitcoin fall more than 30% from its peaks.

MSCI is reviewing whether companies with over 50% of their assets in digital currencies can remain in traditional equity indices. Since Strategy's balance sheet is heavily impacted by its Bitcoin holdings, it is at considerable risk of exclusion. JPMorgan analysts suggested that “MicroStrategy is at risk of exclusion from major equity indices as the January 15th MSCI decision approaches,” highlighting the potential for around $2.8 billion in capital outflows if it loses its position in the MSCI.

If other index providers follow suit, the outflows could total as much as $8.8 billion. The precarious market conditions add to the complexity of the situation, as JPMorgan's bearish communications coincide with Bitcoin's weakness and MSTR's decline.

Increased Short Selling and Account Closures at JPMorgan

According to analysts at Bull Theory, JPMorgan is known to carefully time its market reports—reporting bearish insights when prices are already weak and adopting a more optimistic tone near market peaks. Reports indicate a rise in share lending for MSTR, allowing brokers to lend shares to short sellers, which can worsen the decline in stock price.

Additionally, there is a growing number of reports regarding account closures at JPMorgan, with many consumers claiming to exit due to perceived manipulation concerning MSTR and Bitcoin. In light of these developments, the possibility of a short squeeze is becoming increasingly likely. Analysts believe that should Strategy's stock increase by 40% to 50%, it might create a short squeeze on the bank's position, leading to significant financial consequences.

Michael Saylor, the CEO of Strategy, has attempted to clarify the company’s role, insisting that it is not merely a passive Bitcoin holder. He emphasized that Strategy functions as a software business with an active financial strategy, counteracting the narrative prompted by MSCI’s concerns.

As these events unfold, several important issues are becoming clear. The market downturn on October 10th coincided with the MSCI announcement amidst an already unstable market. The strategic timing of JPMorgan's bearish comments has heightened concerns and added uncertainty as MSCI's final decision approaches.

Strategy
The daily chart indicates MSTR's downward trend, currently trading below $170. Source: MSTR on TradingView.com

Featured image from DALL-E, chart from TradingView.com