Understanding Bitcoin, ETFs, and the Emerging "Dual Strategy"

Bitcoin is navigating a complex landscape in 2025, influenced by the rise of Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) and the foundational principle of self-custody. As investors grapple with these two approaches, many are finding a unique balance that embraces both worlds. This article explores how the dual strategy is shaping the future of Bitcoin investment.

Key Takeaways

Bitcoin is currently influenced by two major strategies: ETFs and self-custody.
ETFs provide easy access and regulatory safety for new investors.
Self-custody remains essential for seasoned Bitcoin users who value control and independence.
Both strategies are stabilizing and mutually reinforcing the Bitcoin ecosystem.
A dual-structured market is emerging, making Bitcoin more flexible and accessible.

Bitcoin, ETFs, and the 'dual strategy' analysts are talking about today

Bitcoin's Dual Strategy: ETFs vs. Self-Custody

Bitcoin [BTC] has been influenced over the past year by two opposing trends: the growing popularity of Wall Street’s ETFs and the fundamental principle of “not your keys, not your coins,” which emphasizes personal control over crypto assets. Instead of choosing one path, many investors are opting to embrace both.

In 2025, the effective Bitcoin strategy isn’t just about being a maximalist or an institutional investor. It's about finding a middle ground that caters to both approaches.

The Shift from ETFs to Self-Custody

ETFs have emerged as a convenient gateway for many investors seeking exposure to Bitcoin without the complexities associated with handling private keys. Their institutional access, considerable liquidity, and compatibility with retirement accounts have made them a primary entry point for newcomers.

bitcoin

Indeed, data from 2024 through mid-2025 shows strong positive monthly spot Bitcoin ETF inflows, with some months experiencing influxes between $4 billion and $6 billion. By July 2025, total net assets reached nearly $140 billion, indicating robust institutional investment.

ETF analyst Eric Balchunas highlighted this shift in an X post, expressing puzzlement over why seasoned investors were comfortable with crypto exchanges holding their Bitcoin but not with ETFs: “It’s the same outsourced custody concept, except ETFs are way cheaper and safer.”

For many first-time investors, the sense of security that comes with Bitcoin held in an ETF is appealing and familiar. This regulated approach aligns well with what a considerable segment of the market desires.

However, for long-time Bitcoin enthusiasts, the fundamental allure has always been personal sovereignty. Hence, self-custody remains a non-negotiable principle for many, despite the ETFs gaining mainstream acceptance. As Sam Wouters, Director of Marketing at River, remarked, “On an exchange, you can withdraw to self-custody at any time, which is not the case with an ETF.”

To these advocates, the freedom to manage one's assets is paramount. They see an ETF as a “bird in a cage.”

Finding a Middle Ground: Control and Strategy

Ultimately, the debate over custody boils down to a fundamental aspect: control. Early Bitcoin adopters were willing to keep their assets on exchanges because they knew they could withdraw at any time to regain full autonomy. ETFs, however, create a different scenario where Bitcoin may be stored but access to it is restricted.

Consequently, a new dual strategy is beginning to take shape. As Bitcoin advocate Fred Krueger noted, “The answer is BOTH: welcome adoption by Banks, ETFs, and the greater establishment… while also encouraging and practicing self-custody. And defend the right to self-custody.”

Currently, many investors use ETFs for convenience while maintaining cold wallets for fundamental control, reflecting Bitcoin's ongoing maturation.

AMBCrypto reported that 2025 has seen 171 days of negative Bitcoin performance, hinting at a possible sideways market trend. With corporate treasuries collectively holding over 1 million BTC—more than major exchanges—this mounting establishment of Bitcoin ownership is starting to establish a new structural foundation for the asset.

ETFs: An Integral Part of the Bitcoin Ecosystem

ETFs enhance liquidity and offer institutions a regulated means to engage in Bitcoin without the complications of direct operations. Meanwhile, self-custody upholds Bitcoin’s essential promise of open access, user control, and the ability to transfer value freely.

These two paths are not in competition; instead, they complement and stabilize each other. This balance fosters a more resilient ecosystem, as ETF demand generates steady inflows while self-custody safeguards Bitcoin’s original essence.

Today, miners, custodians, exchanges, and asset managers operate collaboratively rather than in opposition, resulting in a clearer identity for Bitcoin. BTC is positioned to thrive within traditional financial markets without relinquishing its potential for existing outside of them.

With this dual structure in place, the market is becoming increasingly flexible, accessible, and better equipped to welcome a new generation of users—without the need for purity tests.

Final Thoughts

As Bitcoin evolves, its relationship with ETFs and self-custody illustrates a significant aspect of its growth. Embracing both strategies not only enhances accessibility for newcomers but also preserves the core values that long-time users cherish.